A review of recent progress in the field of waste management, including international and national policy developments, siting announcements and technical progress.


News | Nuclear Intro | Info Briefs | Articles/Opinion | Policy Docs/Treaties | WNA Reports | Nuclear Portal | Symposium | Conferences

WORLDWIDE ADVANCES IN RADIOACTIVE WASTE MANAGEMENT - 1999 REPORT

 

Industry Progress in Waste Management
   

Treatment and conditioning top 

Canada: In January 1999, Cameco Corporation received approval from both Canadian and American authorities to begin shipment of uranium-bearing materials from its uranium refining and conversion plants in Ontario to the International Uranium Corporation (IUC) mill in Utah for recovery of the uranium. Shipments began immediately. These materials contain significant amounts of uranium, but at too low a concentration to be recycled within the refining and conversion plants. Recycling to IUC permits recovery of the valuable uranium resource and eliminates what would otherwise become a waste disposal problem.

France: COGEMA continues to optimise solid waste management at its La Hague plant, in order to reduce both radiotoxicity and the volume of final residues. The latest project concerns long-lived intermediate level waste: mostly hulls and end-pieces. The new facility, referred to as ACC (Atelier de Compactage des Coques, or Hulls Compaction Workshop) received on-site tests which started at the end of 1998. The process reduces the final residue volume by a factor of four. The construction of the ACC began in March 1995 and completion is scheduled for late 2000. Process waste will then account for less than 0.5 m3/ton of reprocessed fuel.

A new plant called CENTRACO (see image below) - operated by SOCODEI (a COGEMA - Electricité de France subsidiary) has been constructed for the treatment of metallic and combustible low level wastes. The first unit of the plant, which implements the melting technology for short lived metallic waste, started commercial operation on 3 February 1999. The second unit started up on 19 April 1999 and incinerates the combustible technological wastes (which include gloves and clothes) and liquid waste. The incinerator design capacity is 3 500 t/year of solid waste and 1 500 t/year of liquid waste.

CENTRACO incineration facility
Click for large view

Germany: A project to develop a facility for the vitrification of the high level waste (HLW) concentrate from the Karlsruhe Reprocessing Plant (WAK) is under-way on the site. The HLW results from operation of the WAK from 1971 to 1990. Since then, it has been stored in shielded, cooled tanks. The construction of Karlsruhe Vitrification Facility (VEK) is expected to start in 2000. The project of vitrification would then be completed by 2005.

The construction of the industrial pilot plant for demonstrating the conditioning of spent fuel for disposal at Gorleben (PKA) will be completed mid 1999. The operating license is expected this year. However, it has not been decided when the plant will start its hot operation. The plant allows the handling and conditioning of spent fuel, high, intermediate and low level waste as well as flask maintenance.

As a possible alternative to the POLLUX-cask disposal concept, the conditioning of fuel rods in a canister of the same diameter as the internationally standardised high level waste canister is under development.

Italy: A vitrification unit using French technology is being designed for the conditioning of some 200 m3 of the HLW and LLW currently stored at the EUREX plant (CORA project). The contract for the project has been signed in a joint-venture with the French SGN. The vitrification station should begin operating in 2001.

Switzerland: Since January 1999, ZWILAG (Zwischenlager Würenlingen AG), the country's project for interim storage for all categories of radioactive waste and for the incineration and conditioning at Würenlingen (see image below) in the canton of Aargau, celebrated near completion. Tests for interim storage are expected to start before the end of 1999. Together with a similar but smaller facility located at the Beznau power plant called ZWIBEZ, this facility will provide sufficient capacity to store all types of radioactive wastes from all reactors plus radioactive wastes from medicine, research and industry.

The federal executive has yet to issue a specific licence for incineration and conditioning. ZWILAG applied for this licence in late 1997. It has opted for a high-temperature plasma oven that thermally decomposes or melts waste at temperatures up to 20 000°C. Melted organic and metallic wastes are made into vitrified residues suitable for disposal.

View of Würenlingen centralised storage for all waste ZWILAG
Click for large view

Interim storage top 

Armenia: The dry spent fuel storage facility at the Metsamor nuclear plant was completed in November 1998. The French government provided the financial backing for the project. After licensing by the Armenian Nuclear Regulatory Authority (ANRA), the new facility will receive spent fuel from the Metsamor plant under IAEA supervision and with the help of Framatome specialists. According to the Armenian energy ministry, the licensing procedure for the store is well under-way.

Canada: All three nuclear utilities, Ontario Power Generation (OPG), Hydro Quebec and New Brunswick Power, have approved dry used fuel storage facilities at their reactor sites. However, the approval of the environmental assessment for the expansion of the site at OPG's Bruce Nuclear power Development is being appealed in a court case brought by a local environmentalist group.

Germany: An interim storage facility for low level waste, at Lubmin, near Greifswald, came into operation in March 1998. Low level waste (LLW) from the former East German nuclear power plants at Lubmin and Rheinsberg, both under decommissioning, will be stored in seven buildings. The facility will also be able to store LLW from other German nuclear plants, but only as an interim measure for two years.

Lithuania: Hot testing of spent fuel casks commenced in early 1999 for Ignalina RBMK NPP dry storage.

Poland: A six month study was completed in September 1998 for spent
fuel management at Swierk, in a partnership between BNFL, Framatome and the Polish Atomic Energy Institute. Swierk, which is owned by the National Atomic Energy Agency and operated by the Atomic Energy Institute, has two research reactors. One is currently being dismantled and the other is still in operation. The study received joint funding from the DG XI of the European Commission and the Polish Atomic Energy Agency. It reviewed the concept of wet on-site storage, assessed current requirements and recommended storage for at least 50 years.

Russia: The Russian Federation, management of the Leningrad RBMK NPP is considering several alternatives in order to have a dry spent fuel storage facility in operation by 2003. Spent fuel from the Leningrad plant is stored in pools, which have enough capacity remaining for another 6 to 7 years.

Spain: Santa Maria de Garona nuclear power plant completed the extension, started in 1994, of its spent fuel storage pool in September 1998. Based on expected output, the extra capacity means that the plant can continue to store spent fuel to 2015.

Sweden: The state Nuclear Safety Inspectorate, SKI, gave final regulatory approval in January 1999 for the extension of the country's interim storage facility (CLAB) for spent nuclear fuel, located at the Oskarshamn nuclear plant. SKI's approval is based on a new safety standard for nuclear facilities which officially takes effect in 1999.

Ukraine: Energoatom announced that a spent-fuel storage facility will be put into service at Zaporozhye nuclear power plant by 2000. Construction is to begin this year and will proceed in stages.

USA: The US NRC issued a license to Virginia Electric and Power Company in August 1998 to allow storage of spent fuel from its North Anna power plant in an independent spent fuel storage installation (ISFSI) on the plant site. The spent fuel, which is currently in a storage pool at the site, will be placed in casks on a concrete storage pad, surrounded by a security fence. Thirty two assemblies can be loaded into each cask and the facility will provide storage for approximately 1800 fuel assemblies. It is licensed for 20 years, with the possibility of a license renewal. The total storage capacity at North Anna is sufficient to provide storage of spent fuel from the two units during their currently licensed operating lives (ending in 2018 and 2020 respectively).

Disposal top 

Canada: Cameco Corporation received approval in late 1998 to convert the Deilmann tailings facility at the Key Lake Operation from subaerial to subaqueous tailings deposition. The mined-out Deilmann pit has been in use for tailings disposal since 1996 with the tailings surface exposed to the atmosphere. The change to subaqueous deposition first involves flooding the pit, by reducing the rate of pumping water from the bottom drain. The tailings will be injected into the tailings already in place by means of a tremie pipe, technology used for underwater placement of concrete. The advantages of the flooded system are elimination of freezing of the tailings in the winter, reduction of radiation emissions from the tailings and reduction of erosion of the pit walls.

COGEMA Resources received approval to do preliminary construction of a tailings facility in the JEB pit at McClean Lake in August 1998. Approval to complete the work was received in March 1999, and operating approval for the McClean Lake uranium mill was received in June 1999, allowing tailings deposition in the pit to commence.

Finland: Low level and intermediate level waste from the Loviisa plant was received by the new on-site final repository in June 1998. The Radiation and Nuclear Safety Authority (STUK) completed a review of the Final Safety Analysis Report (FSAR) in early 1998 and submitted its statement on Imatran Voima Oy (IVO) application for the operating licence to the Ministry of Trade and Industry. In April 1998, the government granted the license for the repository. The repository is designed to host only waste from Loviisa plant, but could also store some waste from medical programmes as well. The repository is scheduled to be sealed in 2055.

France: The operating life of the Aube surface disposal facility for LILW is likely to be doubled. The facility, commissioned in 1992, has a capacity of 1 000 000 m3 which was originally designed to receive about 30 000 m3 of LILW every year. Then, the operating life of the disposal site was then expected to be about 30 years. Because of the improvements made in reducing total waste volume, the volume of wastes to the facility are far below expectations: now half the predicted volumes. New treatment techniques, like those to be implemented in CENTRACO plant, will further reduce total volume of conditioned LILW. The expected volume of waste packages to Aube by 2000 is around 13 700 m3 making a 60 year operating period foreseeable. The former surface disposal facility, Manche, closed in 1994, is currently in the process of being granted the authorisation to pass into the surveillance phase.

Norway: The governmental organisation Directorate of Public Construction and Property has completed the radioactive waste facility at Himdalen, near Oslo. The facility, with a capacity of 10 000 drums, is expected to receive all low level and intermediate level wastes generated in Norway until 2030. The Institute for Energy Technology (IFE) has been granted licence by the government to operate the facility which consists of four caverns constructed in a hard rock formation, with through a tunnel which has about 50m rock coverage above. The waste will be placed in concrete cells. IFE currently operates a facility at Kjeller where wastes produced by the research reactors and other applications are treated and stored. These wastes are in the process of being retrieved and shipped to the new Himdalen facility: an operation that will last until 2000.

Sweden: In November 1998, the prime minister officially opened the SKB canister laboratory, the first facility in the world associated with the encapsulation of spent nuclear fuel for direct disposal, which will test SKB's R&D plan for high level waste management. This pilot plant has been built in order to verify and demonstrate the processes and equipment that will be used to encapsulate spent fuel in SKB's Fuel Encapsulation Plant (FEP). The FEP design has been developed following five years' work with particular focus on remote handling processes. The SKB's KBS-3 package is copper-clad iron. Tests will focus on the welding of the packages and on material stress.

Switzerland: Following substantial research in granite host rock, for the disposal of high level waste (HLW), NAGRA is completing the feasibility for a HLW repository in a sedimentary environment. The study is due to be completed in 2001. In addition the utilities are interested in international repository projects for HLW, which in their view offer considerable advantages to mitigate proliferation concerns and cost.

USA: The first containers from DOE Los Alamos National Laboratory were placed in the WIPP (see image below) underground repository four days after a judicial decision on 22 March 1999 to authorise shipments of TRU non-hazardous waste. Final RCRA permit from the state of New Mexico for all waste is expected in October 1999. In the meantime, shipments from Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory (LLNL) should arrive on a weekly basis until all 17 transports are completed. In addition, Idaho National Engineering and Environmental Laboratory's (INEEL) first shipment to WIPP occurred on 27 April 1999. Waste is conditioned in drums, sealed for transportation into special vessels and bolted to the truck flatbed.

WIPP
Click for large view

State regulators plan to re-license Envirocare of Utah Inc.'s low level waste disposal facility following a review of public comments. The public comments were received mid-June 1998 after a series of public hearings in the county where the facility is located. Under state regulations, the facility has to be relicensed every five years but Envirocare can operate under its existing licence until a new one is issued.

Tunnelling at Yucca Mountain (see image below), started in February 1998 is now complete. The new excavation is known as cross-drift and is an extension of the Exploratory Studies Facility (ESF) and forms a large, five-mile-long tunnel cut into the mountain, allowing experiments for site characterisation to take place. The NRC is developing site specific regulations for the disposal of high level waste and spent fuel at Yucca Mountain, in preparation for implementing standards being developed by Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). In May 1999, industry representatives discussed a new concept for the management of US utility spent fuel with the Senate Energy Committee. The concept proposes the complete abandonment of the interim storage facility that has been the centre-piece of industry efforts for the past few years. Instead, the concept would allow DOE to accept waste at Yucca Mountain in advance of its opening, currently scheduled for 2010.

Tunnelling at Yucca Mountain is now complete

Both the Rocky Flats Environmental Technology Site (RFETS), Colorado and
the Idaho National Engineering and Environmental Laboratory (INEEL), have met all programme requirements to characterise, certify and ship transuranic waste to the Waste Isolation Pilot Plant (WIPP). Authorisations were obtained in June 1998 for RFETS's to ship debris waste, and INEEL's to ship both debris and solidified TRU waste forms. Authorisations were obtained following audits performed by the DOE, the Environmental Protection Agency, the Defence Nuclear Facilities Safety Board, the New Mexico Environment Department, the New Mexico Environmental Evaluation Group and other organisations. RFETS and INEEL are the second and third DOE sites to gain authorisation to ship wastes to WIPP. Los Alamos National Laboratory received the first authorisation in September 1997.

Transboundary movements & other transport top 

Belgium: Technical details relating to the first return shipment of vitrified residues have been finalised. However, transportation, importing licences and agreements for the shipments have yet to be granted by the competent authorities.

France: The third shipment (see image below) of vitrified residues reached Japan on 13 March 1998. A fourth shipment, aboard the Pacific Swan, left Cherbourg harbour on 25 February 1999 and arrived on schedule at Mutsu-Ogarawa harbour in Japan on 15 April 1999.

Return shipment of vitrified residues from France to Japan
Click for large view

Germany: The industry expects that the following the ban imposed since May 1998 of the transport of spent fuel from German nuclear power plants to foreign reprocessing facilities, and of vitrified high level waste from reprocessing in La Hague, to the Gorleben storage facility, will restart in 1999.

USA: The DOE's programme to return US origin spent fuel from foreign research reactors, as part of the non-proliferation campaign, has restarted. In July 1998 a ship carrying irradiated fuel elements from South Korea sailed under San Francisco's Golden Gate Bridge. Final destination is the DOE's Idaho Falls facility. The success in DOE's return of foreign spent fuel shipments may also have a positive effect for the future domestic transportation of spent fuel.

Research top 

Belgium: ONDRAF/NIRAS produced a study for low level waste disposal, as a result of which the government decided that a waste management strategy should be developed that is flexible and reversible, and can become progressively permanent. In order to assist in the choice between shallow land and deep disposal, ONDRAF/NIRAS was requested by the government to research the land at the existing four nuclear sites, as well as some other areas. ONDRAF/NIRAS effectively started their research in 1998, which is expected to last about three years. The aim is to present a report on the suitability of radioactive waste disposal for each area allowing the government to make a properly informed choice. The agency aims to have a LLW disposal site in operation by 2005.

A new R&D contract for the disposal of medium and high active waste in the Boom clay layer, to be carried out between early 1998 and the end of 2003 has been established between ONDRAF/NIRAS, SYNATOM - the company responsible for the management of the Belgium nuclear fuel cycle - and the country's main wastes producers. The programme also includes studies regarding conditioned spent fuel disposal. The contract is part of a more global initiative aiming to provide the authorities with a preliminary Safety Analysis Report for the establishment of a deep repository in clay, for about 2011. Meanwhile, SYNATOM is preparing a feasibility study for a spent fuel conditioning plant to present to the government. The study will take technical, economical, safety, environmental and safeguards aspects into consideration. In conjunction, ONDRAF/NIRAS was requested to study the feasibility of conditioned spent fuel disposal in Belgium. The government requested that the involved parties (SYNATOM and ONDRAF/NIRAS) present a complementary progress report at the end of 1999.

China: In the northwest, geological studies are under-way to select an underground disposal site for high level waste, in a co-operative project between the Chinese and the IAEA.

Czech Republic: Since 1998 the Radioactive Waste Repository Authority (RAWRA), established in 1997, has been coordinating responsibility for the development of a geological repository for high level waste. A conceptual design of the deep geological repository in a reference, non-specified site, has been completed. Also, an environmental impact assessment, time schedule and budget has been completed. In February 1998, eight sites were selected for further investigations.

Finland: Detailed site investigations have been completed for the final disposal of spent fuel from Loviisa and Olkiluoto (encapsulation plant and repository). Environmental impact assessments (EIA) were carried out at all the municipalities under site investigation: Eurajoki, Kuhmo, Loviisa and Âänekoski. The EIA report and the updated safety assessment were submitted in Spring 1999 for approval to the Ministry of Trade and Industry (KTM) and the Radiation and Nuclear Safety Authority (STUK). The safety assessment found that all four sites had suitable bedrock for a geological repository. Other factors such as social impacts and transportation requirements pointed to Eurajoki as the most suitable site.

Posiva applied to the government for a policy decision on building the final repository in Olkiluoto (see image below) in May 1999.

Illustration of planned final disposal facility in Olkiluoto
Click for large view

The next step is a comprehensive review of the EIA report and Posiva's application. The EIA principle allows people from the municipalities involved to bring up specific questions regarding the proposal. Once the KTM has submitted its own statement on the EIA report, the application will be delivered for public hearings in the proposed municipality. The policy decision of the government is expected in 2000, though the decision then requires ratification by the parliament. Construction of the final repository could begin after the 2010 and could be commissioned in 2020.

Germany: Pending a governmental decision regarding further exploration of the site, progress has so far underlined the suitability of the Gorleben salt dome as a repository for all categories of waste, in particular spent fuel and high level waste from reprocessing.

UK: In 1998, the Radioactive Waste Management Advisory Committee (RWMAC) published a report outlining its recommendations on the scope and content of the future core scientific research programme into the disposal of Intermediate Level Waste.

previous section / top / next section